Something strange about ASAN’s flyer about Autism Speaks
31/3/2019 Update: After dissecting ASAN’s 2019 flyer here, I’ve finally figured out what they are doing to get these numbers. I’ve edited this post to remove the speculation.
Consider the facts, they say. So I did. I went straight to the source and found something strange…
Total expenses for current year = 46,739,673
Science = 11,729,054 / 46,739,673 = 25.09%. Correct.
Fundraising = 9,981,115 / 46,739,673 = 21.35%. Correct.
Family Services Grants = 2,497,935 / 46,739,673 = 5.34%. Wait what? This isn’t 4%.
Awareness, Family Services, Advocacy (labelled as “Awareness” & Lobbying by ASAN) = (23,188,019–2,497,935) / 46,739,673 = 20,690,084 / 46,739,673 = 44.27%. Hmm… This isn’t right either. It’s not 46%.
It seems that they took the figures reported as Family Service grants in Schedule I Part II and combined them with the non-doctoral-fellowship grants in Schedule I Part III. This works out to $1,881,045.
1,881,045 / 46,739,673 = 4.02%.
(23,188,019 – 1,881,045) / 46,739,673 = 21,306,974 / 46,739,673 = 45.59%.
However, doing it like this is wrong as only grants that are more than $5,000 need to be reported in this section.
Total expenses for current year = 60,617,406
Science = 19,564,193 / 60,617,406 = 32.27%. Correct.
Fundraising = 12,806,970 / 60,617,406 = 21.13%. Wait what? Why is it 24% on the flyer?
Family Services Grants = 2,524,195 / 60,617,406 = 4.16%.
Awareness, Family Services, Advocacy (labelled as “Awareness” & Lobbying by ASAN) = (25,621,093–2,524,195) / 60,617,406 = 23,096,898 / 60,617,406 = 38.10%.
However, doing the same thing as before, we get 2,239,239 / 60,617,406 = 3.69%.
(25,621,093–2,239,239) / 60,617,406 = 23,381,854 / 60,617,406 = 38.57%.
As for how Fundraising got to be 24%, only ASAN knows.
Now, let me illustrate how strange it is to used non-scientific grants reported in Schedule I as a measure. Here are figures from ASAN’s 2016 990 form.
30,000 / 738,688 = 4.06%.
4.02 / 4.06 = 99%. Is ASAN really taking Autism Speaks (AS) to task for only doing 99% of what they do?
Now for ASAN’s 2015 figures.
ASAN didn’t file a Schedule I in their 2015 990 form. So, 0 / 694,043 = 0%.
Compare this to AS’ 3.69%.
3.69 / 0 = This measure is so stupid that even your calculator will tell you that you cannot divide by zero.